Why I’ll Never Write My Memoir

Life can evolve much differently than we expect.

I often fall back on the old adage to explain life’s twists and turns: “(Wo)Man proposes. God disposes.”

I started writing this blog over a year ago to grease my writing wheels. One day – I told myself – I would write the “great North American memoir.” Admittedly a grandiose ambition, but if you are dreaming anyway, dream big say I.

I wasn’t sure what I expected to learn by writing a daily blog for a year. What I eventually learned surprised me. In terms of writing my own memoir, my lust and ambition had subsided.

I realized I had already written a memoir, in fact, but not in a conventional way. My memoir was written down in a thousand daily journal entries in dozens of journals.

In plaintive emails to friends and supporters. In counseling sessions. Family not so much. Family was more often the subject of painful emails than the recipients.

When the time came for me to set out on a blog writing journey, my intention was certain. I would eventually gather all the words I wrote after that pivotal year and compile those musings in a book that was sure to become a New York Times bestseller.

That bestseller would put me on par with revered writers Mitch Albom and Anne Lamott and dozens of other insightful spiritual and psychological authors whose wisdom I’d ingested over the years.

As you can tell, writers must have considerable hubris and ego to believe sharing their words and insight might have any universal appeal.

I had an unstable and violence-riddled childhood. My parents were unstable and troubled. So they passed on what they knew to me and my two sisters. In logical order, those qualities carried on in me through adolescence and young adulthood and beyond.

Underneath all of the emotional muck that had built up inside me over years, I held onto a single belief: I was worth something and would one day make a contribution to the world that would justify all the pain and upheaval I had lived through and caused.

That once seemed like a noble, if presumptuous, ambition. I now realize that it was an acquired survival strategy. A decades long “Hang in there” mantra that kept me moving forward when I all I wanted on many days was for the ground to open up and swallow me whole.

For the life of me, I could not figure out how a seemingly bright and well-meaning sort, such as myself, could go through daily life and repeatedly make so many dumb and incomprehensible life choices.

I couldn’t figure any of it out until I learned about the impact trauma and neglect can have on a child’s delicate and emerging psyche. I couldn’t figure any of it out until I learned there such a thing as “personal boundaries.”

More pointedly was the learning that it was up to me to set those boundaries for myself and my life and that those boundaries were supposed to be inviolable. And if they were to be preserved and strengthened, it would be my job to do so.

Duh.

How odd these revelations must seem to “normal” readers. Those who grew up with “good enough” parents who provided the necessaries of life and a safe home environment without fanfare or expectation of laud.

Only much later in life did I come to realize my narcissistic mother had an addictive and almost pathological need to hear what a great job she was doing and had done for her children. It was her survival strategy and often tenuous attachment to sanity.

My life today is 180 degrees from the life I lived as a child. I have everything I need and much of what I want. I have a strong and loving relationship with an equally flawed and delightful human being in my husband.

I chuckle a little when I realize my assertion about enjoying a happy marriage would have had as much currency in my family as claiming the moon is made of green cheese. Incredulous and ridiculous my mother would surely say. Yet, here we are.

I am not old enough to have arrived at the rigorous stock-taking phase in old age about what my life was, the part I played in it and how I feel about it all. In truth, some chapters and paragraphs are too painful to revisit. But not all by a long shot.

I had an interesting balance of experiences, adventures and learning opportunities that balanced out the tragedies. There are many stories from those positive experiences that are worth sharing.

Trips to Europe, Egypt, India, Nepal in my youth. Argentina, the Arctic, China, Korea and Hong Kong in mid-life. And now the biggest trip of my life by marrying, pulling up stakes in my home and native land and immigrating South. Who knew it could be even more educational (if by times utterly perplexing) than any of my earlier travel adventures?

Writing and publishing “the” memoir has receded in importance. I have internalized the lessons learned by wrestling with the myriad of issues my childhood forced me to confront and deal with.

That I did more or less successfully is infinitely more gratifying than seeing my name and image plastered on a book cover in bookstores across North America. (Remind me, by the way. Are there still bookstores out there? I’ve been out of touch.)

I now know that all published works are a compilation of applied intellect, imagination and creativity. Even and perhaps especially, memoir. I now write when Spirit moves me to write. Like today.

As for my childish dreams of fame, fortune and global admiration by millions of strangers? That ambition has been traded for the hundred daily satisfactions and frustrations of a happy and peaceful daily life filled with loving friends and family of choice.

For me, that is a more than satisfactory trade-off for the bright lights and big city.

Been there, done that.

Aging a la Anne Lamott

This is not the first time I have dragged writer/author Anne Lamott into the spotlight for well-deserved laud. I love her voice and a whole lot of other things about her.

Sardonic, witty, spiritually grounded and insightful in a no-nonsense, non-preachy way. She’s funny. She gets that god must have a sense of humor to absorb and deflect the mess we masses have made of his/her/its many gifts.

So this piece she has written and had published in The Washington Post is her take on aging. I found it hard at first to put Anne Lamott in the crone category. But, according to the US Bureau of Statistics, at 70, she surely is.

So enjoy her essay/rant about the skulduggery and indignities of aging. And some of the good stuff, too. Lamott is such a pleasure to read and has such a quirky insightful voice that she almost manages to make aging sound fun.

I said almost.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2023/10/30/aging-health-strength-mind-heart/?_pml=1

Write This Way

Writer Anne Lamott is my kind of people. Given her legion of fans, I guess a lot of other people feel the same way. 

She’s wry and witty and insightful and very funny and irreverent but also with a keen felt sense of the sacred and miracles. That seems to be a pretty cool way to go through life.

I found this Anne Lamott excerpt [naturally] at a time when I need it most. We word worshippers are becoming an endangered species. The other night my adult daughter said to me, in passing: “Words don’t mean anything any more.”

It felt like a gut punch. It felt similar to the growing disrespect and lack of civility I feel in business and social discourse these days. [My galling experience flying home to my husband from Canada was a particularly loathsome example of incivility gone wild.]

So when I get the chance to lift up and, indeed, proselytize the words of someone whose worldview I share, I am so on it.

That said, savor this perspective and these book recommendations from Anne Lamott. I actively seek wisdom and insight these days like I used to seek public recognition and booze [cross addictions].

She’s one of the good guys.

Anne Lamott’s 5 Favorite Books for Finding Hope

“I try to write the books I would love to come upon, that are honest, concerned with real lives, human hearts, spiritual transformation, families, secrets, wonder, craziness—and that can make me laugh. When I am reading a book like this, I feel rich and profoundly relieved to be in the presence of someone who will share the truth with me, and throw the lights on a little, and I try to write these kinds of books. Books, for me, are medicine.”—Anne Lamott

“Strangers in Their Own Land” by Arlie Russell Hochschild

“I have been foisting this on everyone since the election. A famed sociologist from Berkeley spends months visiting the Louisiana Bayou and getting to know the people who live there—their values, problems, minds, hearts, lives, and dreams. What they tell us in their conversations and how Hochschild changes by listening to them give me hope for our country.”

“Happy All the Time” by Laurie Colwin

“This is a beautiful, hilarious, big-hearted novel about four really good, slightly odd mixed-up people (like us) as they form couples: shy, worried, and brave. I have given away THOUSANDS of copies.”

“Praying for Sheetrock” by Melissa Fay Greene

“This is one of my favorite nonfiction books ever. It’s about a small backwoods county in Georgia in the 1970s struggling to be included in the progress for civil rights and about the idealists who lead the cause against entrenched racism. It’s a story that reads like a novel, filled with eccentrics and ordinary folks. Lovely in every way. If you read it, you will owe me forever.”

“The Illustrated Rumi” by Jelaluddin Rumi

“I love Rumi so much. I can open this book to any page, read any one of his poems, study any one of the illustrations, and feel spiritually rejuvenated—or at least a little less cranky and self-obsessed.”

“Women Food and God” by Geneen Roth

“This is the most profound and helpful book on healing from the tiny, tiny, tiny issues around eating and body issues that some of us have had for, oh, most of our lives. Charming, wise, funny, and deep.”

Via Radical Reads

The Color of Mom

Writing requires organization and discipline. In order to write a book, you need to make choices about what to include and exclude from your story as the process unfolds. Some writers sit and free-write faithfully, and from this exercise, a book eventually emerges. These writers – I recently learned – are called “pantsers.” They write their book, literally, “by the seat of their pants.” I am normally that type of person on many projects I undertake. In this case, I have been told I have too much material to draw from and too many anecdotes to share. I have to put them in some sort of order. A narrative arc I believe it is called. I explained in an earlier post that I went to a stationery store, and bought lots of writing paper, and bright neon-colored index cards: pink, yellow, blue, pink, and green. “Assign a color to each major character,” I was advised. “Collect your stories and observations about that character on that single-color index card as they come up for you. Carry the blank cards with you so you can jot down ideas that come up on the fly.” I may be overthinking it but I immediately wondered: what color should Mom be? She was a tiny, feminine woman so maybe her cards should be pink. Then again, she was not very much maternal and had a hard and bitter edge. I vacillated while considering the yellow cards. She committed stunning acts both of bravery and cowardice in her lifetime. Does she deserve to wear the yellow stripe of cowardice in my musings? Given our troubled history, it would not have been inaccurate. What about the blue index cards for the sadness and chaos she created in my life and her own and that of many others? And certainly not the green index cards. Poet Irving Layton once wrote a phrase about poets and poetry that has stayed with me: “The poet’s colors are green and black – the colors of life and death.” Green is sacred to me. It has always evoked life and renewal. I’ve painted the walls of my home in shades of green. I crave the fresh green palate I encounter on forest walks. My doctor insists fresh greens on my palate will prolong and enhance my healthspan. I cannot assign this precious color to musings about my mother. Sadly, so much of what I remember about her is sad and sick and life-sapping, not life-giving. I told my husband about the dilemma I faced. He replied immediately: “Perhaps you should make her cards in dual colors.” Duplicity was a strong character trait of hers so that could work. “Put a diagonal across the index card. Write your pleasant memories on one side of the line and the not-so-pleasant memories on the other side.” A logical compromise, I think. But as to the color? Possibly white. White-faced. Bloodless. Whitewash. Cadaverous. A void. I have so few warm or pleasant memories of my mother and that is sad. What I mostly remember is surviving her. For years, my survival was nowhere near a foregone conclusion. We’ll see how the card color selection plays out. Meanwhile, I will take the advice of author Anne Lamott. She advises authors who are reluctant to share bad things that others had done to them to let it all out: “You own everything that happened to you. Tell your stories. If people wanted you to write warmly about them, they should have behaved better.”