I once had one particularly resonant life truth pinned up on my bulletin board among many other nuggets scribbled on bits of paper that spoke to me.
“Eclecticism is self-defeating not because there is only one direction in which it is useful to move, but because there are so many: it is necessary to choose.“
It was more a visceral understanding of that truism than an actual “knowing” that spoke to me. No question I was interested in a great many things as a young woman.
Life dictates you cannot possibly pursue all interests that pop up. Not if you want to achieve any depth of success in any chosen field.
In that respect, journalism was a reasonable path to follow. I got to ask lots of questions about lots of things from lots of strangers. And then I could actually publish or broadcast what I learned. I also got into a lot of high priced conferences by flashing my press credentials.
I worried a lot when I was young about the trap of commitment that making choices and becoming successful requires.
What lay under that fear was constantly questioning whether I was good enough to do anything. I understand that is quite common among human beings. Moreso among women I understand.
I can’t imagine why. (That’s sarcasm right there in case I needed to explain…. Girls do that.)
In the upcoming generation, I feel increasing societal pushback against the extreme standards and expectations that are put on women. There used to be a chart that circulated about how women’s leadership skills compared to how men’s skills were characterized.
He was assertive. She was bossy. He was determined. She was pushy. And so on.
It has always been a devil’s bargain. No matter how well women do, it seems, someone is always ready to “qualify” their success. It took me a long time to understand that.
So I bounced around a lot in my so-called career. Had a lot of jobs. Did some of them more or less well.
I actually enjoy being eclectic. It beats the heck out of being docile and predictable. At least that is what I told myself. Often.
Looking back, I see the truth that eclecticism was self-defeating in respects. But I also dodged a lot of bullets.
I watched senior, single academic women nursing Manhattans in bars after classes were done. I watched another former peer striding proudly as the flag bearer at the front of the annual academic procession during encaenias.
I have watched peers and colleagues zig when maybe they should have zagged at certain junctures in their lives. I know I did a few times.
All the intensity and love they poured into their careers and the strangers that once perpetually peopled their days have now disappeared. They are left with themselves and what is left from that life to comfort them in their dotage.
That seems like a very poor bargain to strike in life to me. Maybe I am speaking from a place of security and safety I had never previously known. Maybe I am a jerk and the truth is I couldn’t keep a job to save my life so naturally, I kept moving forward and moving around.
But I look back on some of those eclectic experiences with satisfaction and huge measure of gratitude for having done some of the things I did.
Trips to the Arctic, Argentina, across the Andes, all over Europe and parts of Asia. High up into the Himalayas. I saw some things that won’t leave until I do.
Young people now seem to prefer collecting experiences over “things” as our parents and grandparents might have. Vast amounts of material possessions are fated for the garbage dump when boomers start kicking off in droves.
I am of the Boomer generation and feel blessed to have adopted a life strategy of accumulating experiences over everything else well before my time.
I am not promoting eclecticism as an optimum life choice. I get and have experienced that spreading your interests too thin can backfire on you.
But I will argue I really didn’t feel I had much other choice. In my bouncing from thing to thing and author to author and one philosophy over another, I finally landed in a place where I feel myself settled and grounded.
For today anyway. It is both the curse and certainty of having an eclectic bent of mind that nothing is ever settled “finally and forever.” Not until death, perhaps, and lately I’ve been questioning if seeking will end even then.
I guess one day I’ll find out. For now, I’m going to scan my eclectic collection selection of saved recipes and see what dish I can concoct that I’ve never made before to see how it works out.
Seems like how I have greeted every day and experience since I’ve been on the planet. Why quit now.